Science funding tends to favour mediocrity over grand ideas
Einstein does not need a subsidy
The type of hobby that can entertain physicists is to imagine writing grant applications to Einstein in 1905. "I intend to investigate the idea that light travels in small pieces," you say. "I will explore the possibility that time slows down speed things up," said another. Imagine what those comments were raised by the evaluators of the Agency for German science funding, there was such a thing existed. Instead, Einstein got to do the work while still drawing his salary as a class of third technical expert at the patent office in Bern. And it was invented quantum physics and relativity.
The moral seems to be truly innovative ideas are not funded - the system is configured to exclude them. To get money for research from government agencies, you must write a proposal that is evaluated by anonymous referees ("peer review"). If your ambitions are too large or unconventional ideas, there is a strong possibility that any good. So the money goes only to "safe" for the proposals Tromp beaten track, timidly advancing the frontiers of knowledge of a few nanometers?
There is some truth in the accusation that give poor support mechanisms. After all, your proposal must specify exactly what we do. But how can you know the results before making experiments, unless the objective of demonstrating that the bleeding obvious?
- response to this complaint, the U.S. National Science Foundation announced a grant award. Next year - if Congress approves - Fellowships for creative interdisciplinary processors (Creativ - oh, I) will be $ 24 million (£ 15.36m) to a "creative unusually high-risk interdisciplinary proposals / high reward ". In other words, we are looking for new ideas that might not work, but it would be great if they do.
The problem is compounded if you tackle a big problem. For a new drug you need chemicals to fight against the AIDS epidemic in Africa will require not only drugs, but the experience of epidemiologists, social scientists, virologists, and more. The buzzword for large solutions and technologies is "transformative" - ??the Internet is changing, Viagra is not. This big-picture thinking is in vogue, the future of the program of the European Commission of new technologies is the promise of a prize of ? 1 billion (now as we speak) next year for projects in the processing light of what is called
Creativ are schemes such as the way forward? Because the funds will be allocated by the administration of individual projects rather than risk the conservatism of the review panels, you may fall on cronyism. And who can say that project managers will be more tolerant and perceptive? In the end, is a Gordian knot: only experts can properly assess the proposals, but, by definition, vision tends to be narrow. It's good that Creative recognizes the problem, but it remains to see if it's a solution. As film production or publication, you must accept that there will be failures. It's a shame that there is no scientific problems can be solved with pencil, paper and packs a patent clerk for payment.
Find best price for : --Creativ----Foundation----National----Science--
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(638)
-
▼
December
(159)
- China plans manned moon mission
- Where have all the working-class leaders gone? | D...
- Eurozone crisis live: Yields fall at Italian debt ...
- FA appeals against Rooney's Euro ban
- The truth about the Khmer Rouge is too big for one...
- The best theatre of 2011: Susannah Clapp's choice
- Former general set to win Guatemalan presidential ...
- Spurs fail with Olympic Stadium appeal
- Arsène Wenger admits wage gap leaves Arsenal with ...
- Bahrain and Libya expose the two faces of Britain'...
- State pension age rise delayed by six months
- NHS waiting times increase for diagnostic tests
- Michael Gove scraps limits on grammar school growth
- 124 Sure Start centres have closed since coalition...
- Fabio Capello says England were 'lucky' to beat Wa...
- Union leaders 'hell-bent' on strike action, says D...
- Chelsea consider entering the race for Arsenal's S...
- Chelsea consider entering race for Arsenal midfiel...
- Police accessed BlackBerry messages to thwart plan...
- 'Wayne Rooney made a silly mistake and I'm not hap...
- George Osborne plays down tax cuts but wants to ma...
- Hiroshima Day, an apt time to question Trident | C...
- Theatre will miss Nicolas Kent | Richard Norton-Ta...
- Will the Family Drug and Alcohol Court survive?
- We must make an effort to encourage future female ...
- MPs condemn tactical mistakes that ruled out victo...
- City can be as good as Barça, says Touré
- Unions are protecting young workers | Helen Flanagan
- Security and intelligence agencies to give evidenc...
- Engineering students at Silverstone search for the...
- How journalists have shaped social policy
- Manchester United's Sir Alex Ferguson vows to 'kee...
- The scale of the challenge is shocking us into act...
- What the teachers of the rioters know
- BA owner IAG beats Virgin to buy bmi
- The artist's artist: ballerinas
- Tottenham's Gareth Bale claims rival clubs no long...
- Chelsea's André Villas-Boas to unwind with motorcy...
- Neil Lennon says Celtic's Islam Feruz had 'head tu...
- Is Merkel ready to switch the ECB printing presses...
- Labour can prosper from NHS debate
- Tuition fees could bring bonanza for humanities
- Teaching schools are our beacon of hope
- Newcastle hopes to salvage Science City in wake of...
- Protesters: Silenced in court | Ellie Mae O'Hagan
- A vocational course is not a 'dead end'
- Irish economic exodus costs Gaelic sports dear
- Afghanistan's first major railway opens up supply ...
- Championship 2011-12: the bloggers' half-term report
- Alex Aldridge | The case of the sleepless lawyers
- GCSE results: more turbulence on the way
- The sticky challenge facing Africa
- Clegg vows to target widening wealth inequality
- Danny Alexander confirms agreements over public se...
- Rail fares to rise faster than inflation
- Nick Clegg takes aim at inequality, bank bonuses a...
- Under-fire Steve Kean bullish before Blackburn's d...
- Andrew Lansley plans NHS vehicle to warehouse toxi...
- Families face fast-track eviction to help landlord...
- Bradley Manning hearing: defence lawyer turns fire...
- Legal world prediction for 2012
- Said & Done: Zdravko Mamic, Gigi Becali, plus Lari...
- French credit downgrade could come 'within days'
- Nicolas Sarkozy: Is France falling in love again? ...
- Revealed: how City fees are eating into our pensions
- Chelsea fans to air concerns over plan to buy Stam...
- Vince Cable: government plans to block illegal fil...
- Inland Revenue risks 'own goal' with challenge to ...
- Embryonic stem cell trial of blindness treatment g...
- Spurs accused of 'spying' on OPLC board
- US must learn from Britain and not cut foreign aid...
- Style guru Mary Portas leads host of TV celebritie...
- Neymar has chance to justify hype against Lionel M...
- David Cameron questioned over £448m cash to tackle...
- Labour's toughest test: the politics of 'no more m...
- Amanda Knox begs judges to 'do justice' in emotion...
- Martin Jol relishes Premier League return with Fulham
- Science funding tends to favour mediocrity over gr...
- Public sector pensions: facing some of the future ...
- Parents create their own junior school
- Coaches help young people get back on track
- Eurozone crisis live: Merkel offers UK olive branc...
- First privately run NHS hospital 'is accident wait...
- Sharp rise in NHS waiting times
- FTSE has worst quarter since dotcom crash
- Children's heart unit wins high court reprieve
- Ed Miliband's £6,000 tuition fee pledge is a stopg...
- City living affects your brain, researchers find
- David Cameron has taken the first steps to solving...
- Westminster council to draft 'civic contracts' for...
- Nick Clegg's attack on David Cameron driven by par...
- Six tips for surviving the Nobel Prize festivities
- Some universities to drop fees to under £7,500
- Police clash with Malema supporters
- UK riots inquiry panel named by Nick Clegg
- Credit rating agencies braced for US downgrade ami...
- Manchester City frustrated by row with Corinthians...
- Iran's nuclear ambitions targeted with broader EU ...
- Comment is free readers on ... happiness | The peo...
- England set to play in Dublin for first time since...
-
▼
December
(159)
0 comments:
Post a Comment